Special Award: Catherine Neely Female Athlete of the Year
- Beth Alexander (2003)
- Alex Anderson (2009)
- Damita Bullock (2001)
- Katherine Card (2006)
- Ashlen Dewart (2015)
- Beth Felts (2004)
- Piper Fowler (2023)
- Taylor Hall (2015)
- Madison Hayes (2021)
- Ashley Houts (2005)
- Rhyne Howard (2020, 2022)
- LaQuisha Jackson (2011)
- Summer Lanter (2019)
- Lanni Marchant (2016)
- Stephanie Napier (2006)
- Lara Newberry (2009)
- Kelsey Jane Nunley (2017)
- Brooke Pancake (2008, 2013)
- Kenya Patton (2002)
- Amy Phillips (2026)
- Olivia Reeves (2025)
- Ashley Renae Rogers (2018)
- Kristen Vredeveld (2012)
- Shannon Wommack (2007)
- May Wood (2000)
- Phoebe Wright (2010)
