Special Award: Reggie White Male Athlete of the Year
- Vonn Bell (2016)
- Adrian LaBrone Bentley (2008)
- Michael Bingham (2005)
- Adarius Bowman (2003)
- Joel Bradford (2012)
- Kyler Burke (2007)
- Wesley Cash (2014, 2018)
- B.J. Coleman (2011)
- Harris English (2021)
- Steven Fox (2013)
- Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (2026)
- Jermaine Harris (2000)
- Orlandus Harris (2009)
- David Helton (2015)
- Jason Holwerda (2001)
- Dakota Hudson (2019)
- Jacob Huesman (2016)
- Stephan Jaeger (2025)
- Patrick Johnson (2023)
- Luke List (2004, 2019)
- Isaiah Mack (2020)
- Jacques McClendon (2006)
- Andy Morgan (2014)
- Gerald Riggs, Jr. (2002)
- Sean Ryan (2010, 2017)
- Cole Strange (2022)
- Davis Tull (2015)
